| Rank | Player | Impact | Franchise | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | +18.2 | Slipping Jimmy | MLB_REF | |
| #2 | +16.63 | Chubby Chaser | MLB_REF | |
| #3 | +13.84 | Betts Big on Bryant | MLB_REF | |
| #4 | +13.76 | Slipping Jimmy | MLB_REF | |
| #5 | +13.69 | Frank Semyon | MLB_REF | |
| #6 | +12.56 | Slipping Jimmy | MLB_REF | |
| #7 | +11.2 | DuJo | MLB_REF | |
| #8 | +11.19 | Noreen Gosch | MLB_REF | |
| #9 | +11.18 | Slipping Jimmy | MLB_REF | |
| #10 | +11.09 | 1 | MLB_REF | |
| #11 | +10.75 | Slipping Jimmy | MLB_REF | |
| #12 | +10.72 | DuJo | MLB_REF | |
| #13 | +10.45 | Noreen Gosch | MLB_REF | |
| #14 | +10.2 | Cornfest King | MLB_REF | |
| #15 | +10.08 | Cornfest King | MLB_REF | |
| #16 | +9.98 | Chubby Chaser | MLB_REF | |
| #17 | +9.52 | Mad About Abreu | MLB_REF | |
| #18 | +9.38 | Frank Semyon | MLB_REF | |
| #19 | +9.36 | Noreen Gosch | MLB_REF | |
| #20 | +9.21 | 1 | MLB_REF | |
| #21 | +9.02 | Mad Dog Tannen | MLB_REF | |
| #22 | +8.9 | Believe 2015 | MLB_REF | |
| #23 | +8.75 | Betts Big on Bryant | MLB_REF | |
| #24 | +8.47 | 1 | MLB_REF | |
| #25 | +7.84 | 1 | MLB_REF | |
| #26 | +7.83 | 1 | MLB_REF | |
| #27 | +7.72 | Sleepy Thumb | MLB_REF | |
| #28 | +7.66 | Noreen Gosch | MLB_REF | |
| #29 | +7.61 | Frank Semyon | MLB_REF | |
| #30 | +7.6 | Mad About Abreu | MLB_REF | |
| #31 | +7.6 | Chubby Chaser | MLB_REF | |
| #32 | +7.57 | Cornfest King | MLB_REF | |
| #33 | +7.44 | Betts Big on Bryant | MLB_REF | |
| #34 | +7.05 | Slipping Jimmy | MLB_REF | |
| #35 | +7.01 | Chubby Chaser | MLB_REF | |
| #36 | +6.87 | DuJo | MLB_REF | |
| #37 | +6.69 | Cornfest King | MLB_REF | |
| #38 | +6.35 | Mad About Abreu | MLB_REF | |
| #39 | +6.19 | Sleepy Thumb | MLB_REF | |
| #40 | +6.18 | Cornfest King | MLB_REF | |
| #41 | +6.12 | Betts Big on Bryant | MLB_REF | |
| #42 | +6.1 | Sleepy Thumb | MLB_REF | |
| #43 | +5.77 | Slipping Jimmy | MLB_REF | |
| #44 | +5.73 | Slipping Jimmy | MLB_REF | |
| #45 | +5.48 | Chubby Chaser | MLB_REF | |
| #46 | +5.46 | Frank Semyon | MLB_REF | |
| #47 | +5.44 | Cornfest King | MLB_REF | |
| #48 | +5.37 | Cornfest King | MLB_REF | |
| #49 | Brandon Belt Unowned | +5.06 | Free Agent | MLB_REF |
| #50 | +5.06 | Noreen Gosch | MLB_REF |